Pics: Top 10 Voices On The Debate On New Surrogacy Bill

New Delhi: On August 24, the government cleared the draft law that will legalise surrogacy in India. If cleared by the parliament in the Winter Session, the Surrogacy Bill 2016 will put a ban on commercial surrogacy.

According to the bill, couples who have been married for at least five years and are infertile can seek a surrogate, that too from among close relatives. Foreigners, overseas Indians, single parents and live-in couples can’t.

The bill has guidelines for regulating clinics, provisions for providing legal aid to surrogate mothers and also simplifies issues of parentage.

surrogacy2
The clearing of the bill seems to have stirred up a hornet’s nest as strong voices – for and against the bill – have emerged. NDTV brings you the top 10 voices that are important to the surrogacy debate.

1024_14

Sushma Swaraj, External Affairs Minister

We have many examples of celebrities who have their own children, still they have gone for a surrogate child. I am pained to say that the procedure that started as a necessity has become a fashion these days. The trend of gay couples having surrogate babies “doesn’t go with our ethos”. 

1024_3

Farah Khan, Choreographer-Director, Had Triplets Via In-Vitro-Fertilisation

I don’t think any woman is doing it for fashionable reasons. I got married at 40. If I had waited I would have been 45. I had my babies at 43. If I had waited till 45, it would have been impossible for me. Are we now living in a country that tells us what to eat, how to dress, who you can have a child with? 

1024_2

Anupriya Patel, Minister of State, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare

What kind of families are these who are using women to earn easy money? The government wants to persuade surrogate women that selling bodies is not the only way to earn a livelihood. 

1024_13

Meena, Surrogate Mother

With price rise making lives of poor families like us difficult, I have planned to utilise the money for my children’s education. Why should I mop floors and earn Rs 3,000 a month when I am getting Rs 3 Lakh for this? 

1024_12

Subhashini Ali, President, All India Democratic Women’s Association

Renting-a-womb has become a commercial exercise and it shouldn’t be that way. There is certainly a need for regulation. The surrogate mother’s rights need to be protected. 

1024_7

Dr Nayena Patel, Akanksha Infertility Clinic, Gujarat

This is a social issue. I have taken up at least 25 cases within the family where there has been give and take of money within the family. Someone gives a jewellery set, someone gives a car.  Nobody gives service without expecting something.

The choice becomes limited to find someone within the family as surrogate mother. If a sister doesn’t have a uterus, the daughter-in-law of the house could be forced to become a surrogate for her. What about the social pressure that she will go through? 

1024_5

JP Nadda, Union Health Minister

Non-negotiable is the exploitation of women. Abandonment of children should not take place.
It’s not a question of imposing moral values, its a question of righteousness. Technological advancement has to be used in the right perspective.

It is our responsibility to save the mothers by stopping exploitation. To take it to its ultimate end, whatever good idea or suggestions will come, we are open to it. 

1024_10Shabana Azmi, Actress, social activist and a campaigner of equal rights for women

I think, in the current form, the bill cannot work and be passed. We cannot do this without enough debate and discussion. We cannot take away the rights of couples. Adoption is a great option, but why impose only one option to childless couples? 

1024_9

Rupal Tewari, Former Journalist Who Chose Surrogacy

As a young professional, I put marriage and kids on the back-burner (perils of working in the competitive and very demanding environment of TV journalism). I married at 35, and when – at 37 years of age – my husband and I decided to start a family, most doctors told us, I had missed the proverbial bus.

After going through an emotional and physically demanding roller-coaster ride for three years that involved multiple IUI and IVF failures, I had my first-born at 40, through surrogacy. I didn’t choose surrogacy so I could avoid putting on weight, or avoid labour pains, or simply because it was fashionable since Bollywood stars were doing it. On the contrary, for the rest of my life, I shall always carry the pain and regret of not being able to carry my own child. So surrogacy wasn’t my first, second or third option. It was my last resort. 

1024_11

Dr Soumya Swaminathan, Director General, Indian Council of Medical Research

While infertility is a growing problem in India, there are many different ways of making a family. Adoption can give happiness to a childless couple and also provide a home and a future for an orphan child. 

 

3 COMMENTS

  1. It should be couples right ,what to have ,when to have and how to have.surrogacy is not for fun it’s a most difficult option for women when she is not able to carry her own child in her womb. Now a days when late marriages is happening, how come anyone wait for another 5 years.This government is insensitive, they have nothing to do with middle-class people,they r busy in comforting adani ,ambani
    When bunch of illetrate and insensitive people will make any sort of bill the outcome will be disastrous.

  2. Women should be given the choice to have a family and child. Most important is the right of choice and not be restricted to choices. Adoption, surrogacy or childless is the ultimate decision of the couple or family and external pressure should not be the reason for having a family.
    We should be more open and learn to promote healthy lifestyle and respect personal choices rather than critiquing family choices.
    Peace!

  3. Hello Minister, you have looked towards only celebrities. Adoption is a great option, but why impose only one option to childless couples? e.g. only close relative. How you will stop someone who will force daughter in law since government has not kept any option for him How government stop exploitation of so called close relative.
    Make steps to stop exploitation through proper cash flow.
    you guys are playing with emotions…

LEAVE A REPLY

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.