How Indian Government Is Shaming People Into Using Toilets: Foreign Media

Swachh Bharat Urban tweeted : Change of attitudes and mindsets are important to achieve #AsliTarakki #MyCleanIndia

New Delhi: India’s government has been on a public toilet building spree. Now, it’s trying to shame people into using them.

An aggressive new campaign ridicules those who are no longer poor but continue to defecate in the open – a practice that remains common in rural India despite its growing wealth and trappings of modern life.

Television commercials and billboards now carry a message that strike at the heart of the Indian contradiction of being the world’s fastest-growing major economy and also where relieving oneself in the open is the norm in most villages.

Since Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s “Clean India” mission set a target of 2019 to end the practice, the government built millions of new toilets.

In fact, the advertisements mock the very idea that India is developing. The tagline says: “Only the habit of using a toilet is real progress.”

And the ridiculing is done by children.

“Uncle, you wear a tie around your neck, shoes on your feet, but you still defecate in the open. What kind of progress is this?” asks a child in one commercial. Another says: “You may have a smartphone in your hand, but you still squat on train tracks.”

Children are also shown making fun of men who buy a new flat-screen TV, refrigerator and a motorcycle but do not use a toilet.

Research shows that one of the reasons for the stubborn social practice is the centuries-old caste system, in which cleaning human waste was a job reserved only for the lowest caste. Having a toilet at home is still considered unclean by many villagers. They regard it cleaner to go to the open farms, which can cause water-borne diseases, the second leading cause of death of Indian children younger than 5.

This is not the first time that the government has attempted to tackle social behavior.

Between 2006 and 2012, authorities gave awards to about 6,000 villages for shifting completely to toilets. But many of them lapsed back because there was no incentive to sustain the new practice.

Brides were asked to shun grooms who did not use toilets. In one campaign, rural men were admonished for making the veiled women in their families defecate in the open. Critics said it endorsed patriarchal attitudes. An unintended fallout of the campaign was that in many villages toilets came to be regarded as important for women, not men.

But now the government is tweaking the definition of modernity a bit. No, not that new bank job in the city; not the motor scooter, or the sofa. It is the toilet.

(Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)


  1. Lastly, when shopping for the quality sofa, ask
    regarding the warranty. Consider the point(s) you’ll would like sofa to serve
    once you consider design style and upholstery options.
    Some contemporary sectional sofa includes numerous separate stuff like two corner sections or
    centre angled part or separate seat sections.

    The kid’s sofa beds provide exactly the same comforts as an ordinary bed does, however with few more advantages.

    In many styles, you can fix the sides in the sofa
    at different angles, from horizontal for sleeping, to slightly
    angled for reading or watching TV.

  2. The most frequent design from the inverter is really a DC source is linked to your transformer from
    the center tap from the primary winding.
    Thanks to its quality, you will ought to pay £80 for your pleasure of comfort.
    Best hammer drills cordless The integrated work light allows you to view clearly when doing work in dimly lit

    The voltage with the cordless phone battery will be the amount
    of energy that this battery has to charge.
    You will also like the fact the handheld vacuum is lightweight and fitted using a D-shaped handle.

  3. If such a thing happens, be sure he understands that
    he needs to discover a place to save lots of, then shut the sport down and redirect him to a different activity.
    Well, basically anything that could be sculpted
    & designed over a computer. Ibuypower gaming pc reviews Christmas is also a stimulating
    time for kids who love games because children have a leave
    from school.

    I feel safe mentioning overclocking, as all motherboards have mechanisms in position that turn off your PC so
    that you can prevent any damage. But you’ll find options to finding the top
    pc for gaming that matches PC gamer’s needs.

  4. You should progress one by one so your body can certainly handle and find habitual
    of the eating habits. For example, some natural weight loss
    supplements work as being a glucophage they take up the excess glucose that is certainly circulating inside your system once you eat.
    Cheap diet pills that work fast without exercise Keep planned that even though they’re called weight loss
    suppliments does not mean that they are going to all be effective in your case.

    Discover the main advantages of African Mango Plus and ways in which it outweighs any supplement possibly you have
    tried for weight loss help and dieting. She continues to
    be working inside the same field and writes informative
    articles, fat reduction being her pet subject.

  5. Than the sooner 1080p plasma models, more attractively, power is consumed
    less. If you might be wondering, how you can connect a laptop that isn’t going
    to have an HDMI connector, then you definitely can work with an HDMI to DVI conversion connector.
    Hdmi to dvi best buy The phone also offers 3G, GPRS 32, and EDGE
    32 for Internet Browsing, Stereo FM Radio, and RDS.

    Many people state if you need to enjoy 3D
    at Full 1080p video resolution, the newest HDMI 1. You really do should
    check into what subscription channel you
    want to get along along with your Roku player but there can be a
    few more options along with all the main pay channels.

  6. First provide them enough water to flush toilets , then ask them to use toilets. They have to walk kilometers to grab a pail of water to drink.
    We as Indian do not look into resources rather jump to non feasible solution first.

  7. Great blog! Do you have any tips for aspiring writers? I’m hoping to
    start my own site soon but I’m a little lost on everything.

    Would you recommend starting with a free platform like WordPress or go for a paid
    option? There are so many options out there that I’m
    completely overwhelmed .. Any suggestions? Thanks a lot!


Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.