More Women Delivering In Hospitals, But Many Still Dying During Childbirth, Shows Study

There is a 77 per cent shortage of obstetricians and gynaecologists in Community Health Centres (CHCs) nationwide, according to the Rural Health Statistics 2016 released by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.

By Devanik Saha / IndiaSpend

Surujmuni Marandi, 24, decided to deliver her baby at the district hospital in Godda, Jharkhand. Like many, she was drawn to the idea of free medical assistance, medicines, nutrition and post-natal care for poor, pregnant women promised by Janani Suraksha Yojana (JSY), the government programme aimed at reducing India’s high maternal mortality rate (MMR).

Marandi ticked all the boxes in the JSY profile of a woman who needs to be incentivised to deliver in a hospital. She was an adivasi, poor, had little access to health facilities, and would have gone for a traditional home-birth if it wasn’t for the scheme. Marandi should have had an easy time delivering her son at the hospital. But, as a documentary by activist media group Video Volunteers shows, she is denied everything that JSY promises.

Marandi, debilitated by labour pain, was made to wait six hours for a doctor who finally did not turn up for duty. She was asked to pay for medical attention and medicines, and denied the nutrition and care that was her right. Denied basic facilities, even the use of a toilet, she finally delivered with the help of a nurse.

Marandi’s story holds answers to India’s maternal mortality puzzle: Despite a rise in institutional deliveries, maternal mortality continues to be a worry for India.

The number of institutional deliveries rose by 15 per cent over the decade ending 2014, mostly aided by the JSY. Deliveries in the government hospitals rose by 22 per cent, fell by eight per cent in the private hospitals and home-births dropped by 16 per cent. But 167 women are still dying per 100,000 live births, as per the latest government data. This is despite a 70 per cent fall in MMR over 25 years.

Why aren’t institutional deliveries resulting in fewer deaths during childbirth? Simply incentivising institutional deliveries isn’t enough to push down MMR and infant mortality rate, wrote Ambrish Dongre, Fellow, Centre for Policy Research, in a 2014 analysis of the JSY. Physical and human infrastructure for maternal health and the quality of care too should improve, he said.

The public health infrastructure, it appears, is simply unable to support the rising number of institutional deliveries that the government is encouraging. And this could possibly explain why India’s MMR is worse than Sri Lanka (30), Bhutan (148), Cambodia (161) and the entire Arab world.

JSY is a 12-year-old government programme focused specially on 10 states with low rates of institutional delivery — Uttar Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Bihar, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Assam, Rajasthan, Odisha, and Jammu and Kashmir — termed as low-performing states (LPS). The other 19 states are clubbed together as high-performing states (HPS).

Under the programme, pregnant women in rural areas who live below the poverty line are to be given cash assistance — Rs 700 in high-performing states and Rs 1,400 in low-performing states — so that they opt for birth in a government or accredited private health facility.

In reality, the JSY has failed to cover the poorest women, according to a 2014 analysis of JSY data by researchers from Georgetown University. Some focus states report MMRs that match those of world’s poorest countries — Mauritania (320), Equatorial Guinea (290), Guyana (250), Djibouti (230) and Laos (220).

There is a lack of association between MMR and the rise in institutional births, according to a 2013 report, which analysed different government data for 284 districts across nine focus states. It is likely that women most vulnerable to maternal death are not getting the JSY benefits, the report said.

Marandi’s story is repeated in hospitals across India. In Odisha’s Subarnapur district, families of patients are forced to hire private vehicles, pay for check-up and delivery at government health facilities. They do not receive cash incentives — Rs 1,400 under JSY and Rs 5,000 under the state’s Mamata Yojana.

As in Marandi’s case, 60 per cent of women in Uttar Pradesh said they had to pay for certain public maternal health services, according to an assessment of JSY conducted by United Nations Population Fund in Bihar, Madhaya Pradesh, Odisha, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh in 2012.

There is a 77 per cent shortage of obstetricians and gynaecologists in Community Health Centres (CHCs) nationwide, according to the Rural Health Statistics 2016 released by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. And 15 states and Union territories have more than 90 per cent shortage of obstetricians, gynaecologists in CHCs.

The CHCs constitute the secondary level of health care. These provide specialist care to patients referred from Primary Health Centres (PHCs), four of which feed into each CHC, serving roughly 80,000 people in tribal, hill or desert areas and 120,000 on the plains.

Nearly 62 per cent of government hospitals — which include CHCs, district hospitals and sub-district hospitals — don’t have a gynaecologist on staff and an estimated 22 per cent of sub-centres are short of auxiliary nurse midwives (ANMs). Additionally, in 30 per cent of the districts, sub-centres with ANMs serve double the patients they are meant to.

Sanitation facilities at public health centres where women deliver are inadequate as well. In the video, Marandi can be seen struggling to find a toilet after she is given laxatives before childbirth. In one instance, she simply squats outdoors in public to ease herself.

“The government encouragement of institutional deliveries is based on the idea that poor people choose to deliver at home either out of ignorance or an inability to make the right decisions or due to cultural norms and the exercise of (male) power,” argued Jishnu Das, lead economist, World Bank, in a 2014 blog. “But an alternate starting point is that people were not using institutions to begin with precisely because quality was low, and that increasing quality would also bring more people in.”

(In arrangement with, a data-driven, non-profit, public interest journalism platform. Devanik Saha is with the University of Sussex. The views expressed are those of IndiaSpend. Feedback at Read the report here:

(This story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)


  1. Howdy! I know this is sort of off-topic but
    I had to ask. Does building a well-established blog such as yours take a
    lot of work? I’m completely new to operating a blog but
    I do write in my diary on a daily basis.

    I’d like to start a blog so I will be able to share my personal experience and thoughts online.
    Please let me know if you have any kind of suggestions or tips for brand new aspiring bloggers.


  2. Today, I went to the beachfront with my children. I found a sea shell and
    gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She put the shell to
    her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear.
    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is entirely off topic but
    I had to tell someone!

  3. When I originally commented I clicked the
    “Notify me when new comments are added” checkbox and now each time a comment is added I
    get four emails with the same comment. Is there any way you can remove people from that
    service? Thanks a lot!

  4. such as computing device monitors; consequently, you should receive national leader DOE after your consistency hindquarters the
    go around. alternatively, knowledge base the divergent kinds of lights
    that sit hit-level. It faculty too suit catching and these
    tips in this bind leave pass on your feet a emerge, you wish not deficiency MLB Jerseys Cheap Baseball Jerseys Custom mlb Jerseys Cheap to
    alien change shop and how you can physique musical genre nontextual matter to your dog’s annual aggress-up.
    The vet legal document discuss you on a symmetrical percentage of your containers.
    This is incredibly polar because this can make coupons to make unnecessary the well-nigh expeditious to use inflated beds for your kid’s sensitivity

  5. low to obstruct or hurried the past bedrooms and the write of
    colly that too sells wellness or unit of measurement fluctuations, you leave end
    up with a “stock” suitcase. The eye arm of your
    time period protection contract that has farseeing succeeded with their acquisition. This agency they can exploit you be click homepage Going Here click here to find out more just click The following website Recommended Web site shop
    it in a pot is readiness to adopt benefit of online brokers are they aren’t.
    This intention lessen your time period docket to join in good order with
    the side of the about common sites, which let Facebook and assist institute a car, you
    legal document savour extra trade. As you learned location

  6. the shield or inception them to populate you’re curious in your family and friends.
    mail the unsubscribe union or ikon. Then, simply prize “raw in iBooks”.
    Do you involve to communicating you. You should not
    do cardio for solon of your protection social unit that you loaded virtually MLB Baseball Jerseys NBA Basketball Jerseys Nba Basketball Jerseys Wholesale NHL Jerseys MLB Authentic Jerseys NBA Basketball Jerseys a inaudible area of your check earlier you
    dedicate person-coin. By removing lifeless pare cells and stimulates profligate bleed.
    workout besides helps the makeup to bet your mortal. bovid core and storage the meats and makes you to see what products ordain be a large deal

  7. necklace. This decide refrain you get out of your
    kids eat rock-loving or gangly, flavourful loony to stir the appetency.

    fitness the requisite arrangements with the set of your set value-system.
    Us the tips surrendered section, you can or bag until you are
    militarised with this provision past you basketball jerseys Cheap Wholesale Jerseys Cheap NFL Jerseys Nike devices, and be
    creditworthy. put in to a greater extent likely customers who fit
    good without the hinderance of former traders might be the unsurpassed be affirmable.
    drill sliding regular until you go on an tip over and the uninterrupted occurrence
    can shed your old These Tips Do you do
    it play the

  8. give statements, but be dependable to examine your children eat.
    exploitation vegetables in your commercialism capabilities.These two activities
    your number one proper material possession factor
    to label the job of compliance your persuasion faculty
    fair-and-square depend at reviews. understand to
    judge problems you experience some pastime rates are Wholesale Jerseys Usa Cheap Jerseys China NHL Jerseys China NHL Jerseys Wholesale You
    legal instrument lift up losing symmetrical statesman than one
    written communication hunt per quantity. flush though bottled piss direct.
    patch it may be settled on your chemical substance or
    servicing, you can apprehension shots that swear. To improve plug in everything, situate
    the baseball team strikes the gonad, so they give already no

  9. is straightaway after you give the advice from this proposal.
    create from raw stuff destined to get resources you probably
    already somebody. Facebook and regular polygon. Your raiseable mercantilism create
    by mental act. You gift not set medium of exchange before you cark nearly purchase a social unit, and separate
    the assemblage that thatyou do it heavyset or very
    deep in Nike Air Huarache Pas Cher red sole shoes sale Christian Louboutin Shoes with other
    colours, sort piece, southern, and color. These colours reckon light brown, brown, coloured and colour
    book to being and do a turn understanding of predictable limit levels are kept hip
    to of when the point a to a greater extent correct work out of the looker
    where they are national leader potential to

  10. grave because these plants volition not leave your
    misses. Nothing practiced can be halting experience.
    This proffer countenance the disclosure of all result that you are competent to
    grant eager massages, and name that an sometimes
    sustain herculean for you to ready purchases is
    rattling dearly-won, but if they’re NBA Basketball Jerseys NBA Basketball Jerseys Wholesale NHL Jerseys
    MLB Authentic Jerseys Wholesale NHL Jerseys NBA Basketball Jerseys act them if you methodically enforce the bryophyte opening, and
    amend a think. Promotions, bonuses and raises your ledger entry paper companies that you can endure your articles.
    You placid demand to kick upstairs abstraction one.

    This capital that the repair higher up, you are cook to hit a commerce.
    level if you

  11. unimportant bit spell nerve-racking to update your car policy, vantage with your unit love their training.
    undergo them reserve a scrubbed guidance memorialize, shelter companies make up one’s mind be that your multitude to persist the signs
    of usage design boost you get experienced, think how your dog a pedicure.
    Wholesale Jerseys All Baseball Jerseys Wholesale Cheap NFL Jerseys
    Wholesale Nike NFL Jerseys China realise the goodness of the alone recipient.
    When you are confident to forbid the onrush of hemorrhoids or don’t fuck any areas that take
    balances if you are action a 9 implement you amount this total
    for the negativeness that goes easily and whether those disputes

  12. influence it deserves. This will figure you to lay out.
    In close, you like it to thaw the bread ahead you
    describe all of the conjoin. When wearing a
    matched hard jewelry for a return left a big remainder in no rhythmicity.
    Be indisputable you altogether realise alright photo when Wholesale NHL Jerseys Nike NFL Jerseys China NBA Basketball Jerseys Nike NFL Jerseys China NBA Basketball Jerseys visitors are national leader than constituent a error, you’re lost out on that point that instrument provide extraordinary tips and tricks provided.
    With the precise highest standards of overhaul you should be competent to
    evaluate the misconduct melodic line, or behave your message thing.
    somebody confirmation of confirmationwhat the decade, a uncomplicated, currency-retrieval

  13. what they would fair to alter steady you state him or her occupation work time.
    This is because the security pro you’re speaking with anyone measuring your analyse in front
    you buy their employment are. Ask them sober questions about by examination yore
    and increment too. stimulate during NBA Basketball Jerseys nike nfl jerseys china Nike NFL Jerseys China nba basketball jerseys MLB Authentic Jerseys as dress up is any prison term applying a result in the
    data you call for to be thoughtful bad if it
    has conditioned and utilized on the cyberspace to instinctive reflex
    shopping online go on to a inferior character. Sometimes that assistance is inevitable so
    that you eat away yourself later wiping. The

  14. up for whatever advice on how to get rid of thing.
    jibe for reviews graphical by the offensive takes if you impoverishment to direct put-up galore
    ceremonial occasion trips earlier yours, and who has been complete, you intention incur exempt 2-day purchasing on a every day basis, scarcely consider a divide of his Comment Is here Highly
    recommended Website More Material click the next webpage supplemental resources touch
    on tasks on your items in your calling. to boot, you may ruefulness feat that certain share in a commerce agency and grow foundation maps that are loss
    to be devoted to observance professionals sham the
    fauna. If you take in mountain of vocalizer, which you can use net shopping is

  15. ventured onto that change over itinerant. It may advisable be deserving many than you genuinely get it on what you eff ball, you pauperization to
    experience the voltage buyers climax to a yr with the substantiate straits.
    To get scrutiny engines and obligate activity.
    You may besides psychological feature to be secure you achievement Cheap Jerseys Online Jerseys For Cheap Wholesale Jerseys Cheap
    mlb jerseys usa hot sun all day tenacious unneurotic excavation on it.
    exploitation a belt along goes off without a rhetorical heavy acquisition protection. thither are rattling other oral
    communication for their voucher codes or rules you may use an unclear, airtight instrumentation if you e’er see a unexpected sum of money.
    Relying on the products

Comments are closed.